EU interconnectors threaten security of UK energy supply, warns Tory think-tank

Increasing electricity imports from the EU threaten British energy security of supply whether Brexit happens or not.

That is the key conclusion from an expert report published today by the Thatcher-ite Centre for Policy Studies.

Britain’s energy strategy, as set out by the Government, is to replace its old coal fired and nuclear power stations with a blend of renewables and new gas fired power stations.
 
But the Government is failing to meet this ambition. The 2012 Gas Generation Strategy estimated that 26 GW of new gas generation would be needed by 2030. Yet the actual amount of new domestic capacity being created is falling well short.
 
Britain has therefore begun – with little public acknowledgment – to import an increasing amount of electricity from continental Europe. It is now projected that the UK will receive 67 TWh of power from undersea interconnectors by 2030, which is a tenfold increase in the projection made in 2012. 

Tony Lodge, Research Fellow at the Centre for Policy Studies and lead author of the report, said: “At a time when spare electricity generating margins across Europe are falling, it does not make sense to build an infrastructure which risks making the UK over-dependent on imports. 

“There are significant supply, cost and market distortion implications of doing this at a time when the Government should be looking to strengthen energy security and reduce bills.  It would make much more sense for the UK to build up a safe electricity supply surplus from generators in Britain on a fair and level playing field.”

‘The Hidden Wiring’ by Tony Lodge and Daniel Mahoney – to be published today – shows why a move towards a greater reliance on imported electricity could be problematic. Its key conclusions include that: 

  • Interconnector capacity will almost quadruple by 2030, allowing 20% of UK electricity to be imported from Europe.
     
    Interconnectors can be a useful way of delivering secure and cheap supplies across Europe, given they can be used to import and export.
  • But in Britain’s case it is increasingly one-way traffic. In the 12 months to March 2017, the UK imported 17.22 TWh but only exported 2.78 TWh.

 

There are concerns about growing reliance on imported electricity from Europe as surplus supplies there decline. This is particularly the case in light of the German elections. Germany is already decommissioning its nuclear plants. If the Greens form part of the governing coalition, as is likely, they will demand the closure of fossil-fuel plants.
 
The more reliant Britain becomes on energy imported from Europe, the more vulnerable we become to disruptions in supply, to sudden price spikes, or a wider tightening of capacity which pushes up prices.

This imported electricity also has an unfair competitive advantage, as it is not subject to the GB Carbon Price Floor or transmission charges faced by British generators.
 
Indeed, rather than cutting carbon emissions, Britain is to some extent “offshoring” them – closing down our own coal fired power plants but continuing to buy energy from Europe which is likely to have come from plants of the same type
 
National Grid’s responsibility for managing the grid and transmission lines gives it a vested interest in building and promoting new interconnectors, rather than in promoting the creation of adequate domestic capacity.
 
In response to these conclusions, the report argues that the UK’s energy policy must prioritise the building of new gas fired power to deliver energy security. The paper also argues that the Competition and Markets Authority should investigate the role of interconnectors.

23 Oct 2017

 

Pixie Energy

Pixie logo Pixie Energy is an incubator and a facilitator of strategic research and project work, focusing on energy regulation, policy and markets at the local and national level. Find out more about Pixie Energy here.

Local Energy Matters: Scotland

Local Energy Matters: Scotland is a free-to-download brochure with a focus on energy tariffs in the two Scottish electricity distribution regions, as well news on local energy and low-carbon schemes.

Previous editions can be download here.

Scottish energy market overview

You can read an overview of the Scottish energy market here.

Scottish Government energy feed