German government upholds fracking ban – and it’s unlimited

Drilling for shale gas remains under an unlimited ban, said German Environment Minister Barbara Hendricks, dismissing media reports of government intentions to soften the fracking ban. But she did not rule out certain ‘rare’ exceptions EurActiv Germany reports.

Barbara 1This week when she spoke to Deutschlandfunk radio she explained:

“In general, fracking with environmentally toxic substances is prohibited.

“That is also what we determined in the coalition agreement and this ban absolutely does not expire.”

Over the weekend, Der Spiegel reported that the German government was planning to soften its ban on commercial fracking. The news magazine wrote that trial drilling was possible if expert committees made up of at least six scientists showed no concerns.

In addition, the report indicated intentions to omit a paragraph stating that only fracking deeper than 3,000 metres would be permitted. A corresponding measure was expected to be passed through the Bundestag this year, Der Spiegel’s article read.

The compromise was supposedly mediated by Chancellery Minister Peter Altmaier, at the initiation of the economic wing of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU), the Mining, Chemicals and Energy Trade Union and the Federation of German Industries.

The Bundestag’s factions are currently in deliberations over a measure on fracking. “Once these agreements are concluded, the draft law will go into consultations among the departments and then it will soon be ripe for the cabinet and be approved,” explained deputy government spokesperson Christiane Wirtz on Monday.

But Hendricks dismissed Der Spiegel’s report. Commercial fracking above 3,000 metres will not be permitted, she told Deutschlandfunk.

The German government’s expert commission has the possibility to express its opinion, she indicated, “but the ban is still valid: fracking is prohibited for a depth less than 3,000 metres,” Hendricks emphasised. Trial drilling can be conducted for scientific reasons, but only without the use of water polluting fracking substances, the Environment Minister said.

A spokesperson of the Environment Ministry explained earlier this week that the commission is charged with the task of advising decision-makers:

“A recommendation is made on the basis of science and technology but it is not binding in any way. It can declare a recommendation for fracking or it can do the opposite. But water law authorities in the regions are the ones who decide whether or not to permit fracking. The commission does not change anything in this regard.”

Within the coalition, Hendricks said she pushed for an unlimited ban on fracking at the time, attempting “to only permit it under very rare exceptions.”

At the same time, she did not rule out the prospect that gas fracking could be allowed in Germany at some point in time and said:

“If, at an unforeseeable time, it can be scientifically proven that [fracking] is completely harmless, then it may no longer be permanently forbidden.”

The Environment Ministry’s spokesperson also did not consider it impossible for fracking to be permitted at a later date. The spokesperson said:

“The state of science and research is not static; it is constantly evolving. That is why it would be completely wrong to set in stone such a ban on commercial fracking. That is neither how the state of science nor technology work in a democracy.”

In the United States, the fracking boom created a drop in energy prices, boosting the economy. In the meantime the branch has been put under considerable pressure amid quickly falling oil prices.


This piece comes from EurActive and there is more information on that site at Energy

Pictured is German Environment Minister Barbara Hendricks




Pixie Energy

Pixie logo Pixie Energy is an incubator and a facilitator of strategic research and project work, focusing on energy regulation, policy and markets at the local and national level. Find out more about Pixie Energy here.

Local Energy Matters: Scotland

Local Energy Matters: Scotland is a free-to-download brochure with a focus on energy tariffs in the two Scottish electricity distribution regions, as well news on local energy and low-carbon schemes.

Previous editions can be download here.

Scottish energy market overview

You can read an overview of the Scottish energy market here.

Scottish Government energy feed