Energy MPs tell Rudd: “Stop moving the goal-posts and do more to cut bills and tackle fuel poverty through better energy-efficiency”

Energy efficiencyThe Government must do more to reduce consumer gas and electricity bills by improving the energy efficiency of new and existing homes – including reinstating the zero carbon homes policy scrapped following the election.

These are the main conclusion of a new report by MPs on the Westminster parliament’s Energy and Climate Change Committee in the lower house.

The energy efficiency supply chain has been affected by inconsistent and unpredictable policy signals, the report warns, as various schemes have been chopped and changed.

In the last year the Government has announced an end to the Green Deal and reneged on a long-standing commitment to require all new homes to be zero carbon from 2016. The zero carbon homes policy would have saved future homeowners money on their energy bills.

It should either be reinstated or the Government should set out a similar policy that will ensure that new homes generate no net carbon emissions and are inexpensive to heat and light.

Angus MacNeil
Angus MacNeil

Angus MacNeil MP, Chairman (SNP, Western Isles) said: Investing in warmer and more energy efficient homes is a ‘win win’. For consumers it will mean lower energy bills and warmer homes that are more comfortable to live in.

“And as a country we can increase our energy security, cut the UK’s contribution to climate change and reduce costs by not unnecessarily generating more energy than we need.”

 “We need to ensure all new houses are super insulated and fit for the future by reintroducing a zero carbon homes policy, especially as many building companies are prepared to deliver it, but it is the improvements we make to Britain’s existing housing stock that will make the most difference.

“Because many of our homes were built before the Second World War, Britain has some of the most inefficient and heat-leaking housing in the world.”

“Extra incentives need to be considered, as the Government’s previous pay-as-you-save efficiency scheme – the Green Deal – failed to entice enough people to insulate their homes. Stamp duty and council tax discounts could encourage more households to make energy efficiency improvements.”

“Sudden policy changes in this area, like other areas of energy policy, have created uncertainty in the market. It is crucial that the Government establishes a stable long-term framework for energy efficiency.”

The Committee also has serious concerns regarding the Dept. for Energy’s (DECC) proposed approach to tackling fuel poverty through energy suppliers. The inquiry heard that the Government’s decision to use the new supplier obligation to do so may be misguided and that we are the only country in Europe to take this approach.

Commercial energy suppliers may not be best placed to reach those households who need it most, and a scheme which places costs on the very households it is designed to help is inherently regressive.

The report calls on Government to re-evaluate the best approach to tackle fuel poverty. Given the huge number of homes yet to benefit from energy efficiency measures, the MPs also say that the reduced ambition of the new supplier obligation is a major disappointment.

The Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC) must also reinvigorate the ‘able-to-pay’ market, the MPs argue.  There is now no support to help households who wish to install energy efficiency measures but cannot meet the costs upfront. DECC should also communicate the wider benefits of energy efficiency, understand the needs of different households, and encourage a locally-led approach.

The report calls on the Government to consider making energy efficiency a national infrastructure priority. This approach would put energy efficiency much more at the forefront of energy policy making and create a sustainable and durable long-term policy view that goes beyond parliamentary cycles. 

Commons Energy Cttee report on Energy Efficiency Mar 2015MacNeil  – whose constituency has some of the highest rates of fuel-poverty in the UK – concluded: “There is no ‘silver bullet’ to improving home energy efficiency. A combination of regulations, subsidy programmes, obligations, targeted grants and long term structural incentives must all be used in a concerted effort. A one-size fits all policy cannot bring about the change that is needed.

“If the Government takes action now it can help to insulate consumers from future energy price rises, while preventing the requirement for wide-scale retrofits and costly energy efficiency programmes in the future.

“Ministers should see taking action on energy efficiency as a cross-departmental priority. Action is not a cost today, but an important investment for the future.  The cheapest form of energy is the energy that we don’t need to use.”

Meanwhile, the Westminster parliament’s Scottish Affairs Committee is due to take evidence today (14 March) in Stromness, Orkney as part of its inquiry into the renewable energy sector in Scotland. It will take evidence from the following:

  • Councillor Stephen Hagan, Orkney Islands Council
  • Lorna Richardson, Policy officer, Convention of Scottish Local Authorities
  • Felix Wight, Development Manager, Community Energy Scotland
  • Ian Johnstone, Senior Consultant, Aquatera
  • Alistair Gray, Chairman, Hammars Hill Energy
  • Neil Kermode, Managing Director, European Marine Energy Centre

Neil Kermode, Managing Director, EMECNEIL KERMODE (pictured, left) is one of  many prominent speakers presenting at SCOTLAND’S RENEWABLE FUTURE conference in Edinburgh on 26 May 2016. For more information:

Pixie Energy

Pixie logo Pixie Energy is an incubator and a facilitator of strategic research and project work, focusing on energy regulation, policy and markets at the local and national level. Find out more about Pixie Energy here.

Local Energy Matters: Scotland

Local Energy Matters: Scotland is a free-to-download brochure with a focus on energy tariffs in the two Scottish electricity distribution regions, as well news on local energy and low-carbon schemes.

Previous editions can be download here.

Scottish energy market overview

You can read an overview of the Scottish energy market here.

Scottish Government energy feed