Growth in Scottish renewables is hampered by investor uncertainty over UK Govt. policy U-turns – MPs report

Scottish Affairs Committee Report on renewables in ScotlandThe prospects for growth in Scotland’s renewable energy sector have been hampered by the uncertainty caused by recent changes in UK government policies affecting the industry.

This is the key conclusion of the inquiry into the renewable energy sector in Scotland by MPs on the Commons’ Scottish Affairs Committee, published today.

The Committee found that significant growth of the renewable sector in Scotland in recent years has demonstrated the benefit of a supportive policy environment. Electricity production from sources as diverse as wind, hydro and biomass has attracted significant investment.

Growth has been strong enough that it is estimated 21,000 people are now employed in the Scottish renewable sector, which produces almost 30% of the UK’s renewable electricity.

There are, however, concerns that recent changes to subsidies for technologies which generate renewable electricity and uncertainty about future support have affected the confidence of investors in supporting the deployment of new generating capacity. The removal of subsidy for onshore wind in particular, one of cheapest renewable sources of renewable electricity, without consultation with the industry or Scottish Government is considered particularly troubling.

Electricity generated in rural areas costly to transmit to urban centres

The lack of clarity about renewables policy has exacerbated long-standing concerns in Scotland surrounding transmission costs. Renewable plants, most often located in rural areas or on the Scottish Islands, face inadequate grid connections and high transmission charges to reach the urban areas where electricity is most needed.

The Committee calls on OFGEM to look into levelling connection costs across the UK and calls on the UK Government to take action to support the improvement of infrastructure between the Scottish Islands and the mainland.

Pete Wishart, MP
Pete Wishart, MP

Committee Chairman Pete Wishart, MP, said: “During the course of this inquiry it has been encouraging to see how Scotland has taken to renewable energy, and now produces over a quarter of the UK’s renewable electricity.

“This is an important sector of Scotland’s economy, and also makes a vital contribution to meeting our commitments to tackle climate change. The sector’s future success relies on a supportive policy framework in both Westminster and Holyrood.

“This report considers several policy changes the UK Government has made to support for renewables – early closure of the Renewables Obligation for solar and onshore wind, cutting support through Feed-in-Tariffs, and delaying the next round of Contracts for Difference – which we found have weakened investor confidence in the renewable sector, and put at risk opportunities for future growth.

“We have urged the Government to clarify the future support which will be available to the renewable sector, and set out how they will work with the Scottish Government to develop a clear, long-term plan that will allow renewable energy to remain a central part of the energy mix.”

“The report was produced before recent changes to the structure of Government with the abolition of the Department of Energy and Climate Change, with its responsibilities moving to a new Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy – but this change indicates a troubling shift in the Government’s priorities.”

In response, a spokesman for the UK Dept of Business and Energy (which incorporated DECC in last week’s Cabinet re-shuffle) said: “In the last funding round over 40%  of successful UK projects were based in Scotland and further details of the new round will be made soon.”

See also:

EXCLUSIVE: Lies, Damned Lies, and DECC statistics: MPs’ savage report into Green Deal ‘energy in-efficiency’ scheme offers clue to why DECC was abolished

Pixie Energy

Pixie logo Pixie Energy is an incubator and a facilitator of strategic research and project work, focusing on energy regulation, policy and markets at the local and national level. Find out more about Pixie Energy here.

Local Energy Matters: Scotland

Local Energy Matters: Scotland is a free-to-download brochure with a focus on energy tariffs in the two Scottish electricity distribution regions, as well news on local energy and low-carbon schemes.

Previous editions can be download here.

Scottish energy market overview

You can read an overview of the Scottish energy market here.

Scottish Government energy feed