John Muir Trust joins Holyrood campaign for equal rights of planning appeal over Scottish energy developments


Helen McDade,  John Muir Trust
Helen McDade, John Muir Trust

The John Muir Trust has joined a range of environmental and community organisations to support a campaign for fair decision making in the Scottish planning system.

The campaign group Planning Democracy is calling for Holyrood to introduce ‘equal rights of appeal’ to create a level playing field between commercial wind parc developers and onshore oil and gas drillers on the one side, and local communities and environmental groups on the other.

Planning Democracy campaigns for a fair and inclusive planning system in Scotland. A registered charity, its volunteers who include representatives of three community councils with years of experience in planning issues. The nine-member board, chaired by Clare Symonds, is supported by a network of members and advisers.

Under the current system, a developer has the right to appeal against a decision by a planning authority – an option that is not available to any community group or environmental charity which challenges an application.

After lodging a petition to the Scottish Parliament, Planning Democracy has now submitted four case studies from four disparate parts of the country – Shetland, the Borders, the Central Belt and the Highlands ­– to highlight the injustice of the current planning system. The examples cover applications for fracking/ on shore oil and gas, wind turbines and major construction projects.

Helen McDade, Head of Policy, John Muir Trust said: “As things stand, the odds are stacked in favour of developers. They have an automatic right of appeal when a decision goes against them, while local people are left powerless to challenge the verdict of a planning authority or a government minister.

She pointed to the example of the Viking Wind Farm, a joint project between SSE and Shetland Council (through the mechanism of the Shetland Charitable Trust). The proposal to build a 103-turbine wind was opposed by thousands of local residents and by the government’s own statutory agency, Scottish Natural Heritage.

The campaign group, Sustainable Shetland, has taken out a judicial review. 

McDade said: “As joint developer, Shetland Council had a huge financial stake in this application. Yet because they failed to object to their own proposal, there was no obligation on the Scottish Government to hold a Public Local Inquiry.

“Instead, the Scottish Government approved this application – and the community had no right to appeal. Consequently, the biggest wind farm north of the Central Belt was approved with zero public scrutiny.”

“However, the huge expense of taking legal advice is unaffordable for most communities,” warned McDade. “It is also inadequate as the decision on whether to proceed is further skewed in favour of developers by the fact that the expense incurred is only to challenge the legality of the process, and not the rights or wrongs of the decision itself.”

See also today:

Govt. to launch nationwide Scottish energy planning portal following Scottish Energy News campaign


Pixie Energy

Pixie logo Pixie Energy is an incubator and a facilitator of strategic research and project work, focusing on energy regulation, policy and markets at the local and national level. Find out more about Pixie Energy here.

Local Energy Matters: Scotland

Local Energy Matters: Scotland is a free-to-download brochure with a focus on energy tariffs in the two Scottish electricity distribution regions, as well news on local energy and low-carbon schemes.

Previous editions can be download here.

Scottish energy market overview

You can read an overview of the Scottish energy market here.

Scottish Government energy feed