Referendum result ‘good news for Scottish renewable subsidies’

green union jackCommenting on the impact of the Scottish referendum outcome on the energy market, a leading industry analyst has described the outcome as being ‘good for continuing subsidies to the Scottish renewables’ sector’.

On the impact on renewables, Ben Warren, Environmental Finance Leader at EY UK & Ireland, said: “The cost of subsidising renewable energy has traditionally been spread across the UK.

“The referendum result is positive in that Scotland now won’t be left to pay the lion’s share of subsidies – given that this is where most of renewable energy is generated.

“The renewables sector still has to face the difficult choices that the new contract for difference (CfD) feed-in tariff regime, the threat of budgetary constraints and further solar subsidy revisions bring, as well as fatigue from constant policy tinkering.

“And with the current levels of energy market reform underway, the UK’s energy sector was not looking forward to having to digest the impact of an independent Scotland.”

“We know how prolonged policy uncertainty can impact the attractiveness and viability of renewables investment and cause project delays.

“The UK fell to 7th place in the latest Renewable Country Attractiveness Index (RECAI) and we will be reviewing its position moving forward.”

And the ‘no’ result is also good for a continuing integrated UK energy supply sector, said Tony Ward, Head of Power & Utilities at EY UK & Ireland, who added:

“A ‘No’ vote is important for the whole of the UK in that it allows the established dynamic in the energy markets to continue its current course.  

“The UK markets have developed ever – closer and more integrated systems and ways of operating that serve to reduce, then smooth, the cost burden across all users. This also enables investment choices to be made on system-wide merit and help achieve a degree of energy security that can often be taken for granted.

“A major uncertainty has been removed by the vote, particularly for those who were evaluating significant capital investments in Scotland. The EMR reforms and further developments of the UK’s competitive retail market can now progress while taking the UK market into account as a whole.

“The un-picking of this fully integrated market would have likely led to the creation of a significant degree of asymmetry in the separated markets, particularly in respect of the allocation of costs and assets. This is now smoothed by the ability to adopt a nationwide approach.”

Meanwhile, Hector Grant, Chief Executive of the East Kilbride-based Industrial and Power Association (IPA) commented: “This decision by the Scottish electorate to remain part of the United Kingdom ends two years of debate.

“The power industry is keen to move forward and see how the additional devolved powers offered by Westminster will affect us and whether this will lead to an increase in investment for generators and the grid.

“Along with all other industries and business we will be monitoring the political developments over the coming months and will of course be keen to contribute to the discussions.”

* The IPA is organising a Power Scotland Conference in Glasgow entitled ‘The Power Industry and the Impact of The Scottish Referendum’ on 22 October 2014 where, through presentations and debate between the industry and legislators, it plans to contribute to the discussion on further devolution.


Pixie Energy

Pixie logo Pixie Energy is an incubator and a facilitator of strategic research and project work, focusing on energy regulation, policy and markets at the local and national level. Find out more about Pixie Energy here.

Local Energy Matters: Scotland

Local Energy Matters: Scotland is a free-to-download brochure with a focus on energy tariffs in the two Scottish electricity distribution regions, as well news on local energy and low-carbon schemes.

Previous editions can be download here.

Scottish energy market overview

You can read an overview of the Scottish energy market here.

Scottish Government energy feed