Scot-Govt. moratorium on coal-gas may breach human rights under EU planning law, warns top legal energy expert

Ewan Macleod,
Ewan Macleod,

EXCLUSIVE By Scottish Energy News legal affairs correspondent

The Scottish Government’s recent announcement that it would be putting in place a moratorium on granting planning permission for Underground Coal Gasification (UGC) projects until the outcome of a potentially lengthy independent investigation could result in claims under the European Convention on Human Rights.

The Scottish Government has appointed Professor Campbell Gemmell, the former Chief Executive of the national environment agency SEPA to lead an investigation of unspecified scope and duration into “the issues and evidence surrounding UCG.

In tandem with that announcement, Scottish Ministers issued a legal Direction to local Planning Authorities which requires them to advise Ministers if they receive applications for UCG development. Ministers will then have the opportunity to consider whether they, rather than the council in question, should determine the application. A separate Direction of similar effect has also been issued to SEPA in relation to applications for necessary consents under water environment legislation.

It is important to appreciate that any UGC project will have to go through a full environmental impact assessment process under planning law and be subject to extensive local consultation before an application for planning permission is submitted, and it is likely that any of the issues that Professor Gemmell might want to explore will be dealt with in detail for each UCG project.

Regardless of the announcement, planning authorities and Scottish Ministers have an ongoing legal duty to determine planning applications.

The ECHR guarantees the applicant the right to his application being determined within a “reasonable period of time”. If those rights are breached the applicant may apply to the Courts to force a decision to be taken on the application and may be entitled to damages.
Shale energy post conference logo  SEA
Shepherd and Wedderburn Partner, Ewan MacLeod – a keynote speaker at the recent UK Shale Energy Conference (organised by the Scottish Energy Association and Scottish Energy News) suggests that a failure by Ministers to take a decision on a planning application simply because the independent investigation has not been completed could result in a breach of the applicant’s human rights.

MacLeod, who is an accredited expert in planning law, stated that: “Potential applicants will no doubt agree with Fergus Ewing’s commitment to a “full and careful consideration of the potential impacts” of underground coal gasification.

“However, a properly prepared application will undoubtedly contain all of the information that Ministers need to understand the impacts of the project in question and to decide whether planning permission should be granted.

“The ECHR guarantees applicants the right to have their applications determined within a reasonable timescale.

“I struggle with the concept of a national moratorium on taking individual decisions when the all of the key information for the project in question is already available. That would seem to raise clear human rights issues for the applicant which they would be entitled to enforce through the Courts.”

Following the success of the first UK Shale Energy Conference in 2015, Scottish Energy News is collaborating with the Scottish Energy Association to hold the 2016 UK Shale Energy Conference in Glasgow in September this year.

And in addition, Scottish Energy News is collaborating with the Energy Institute at the University of Aberdeen to hold the first ‘collaboration conference’ on how – in the national interest – we can help the UK oil and gas industry get MER out of the North Sea. This event will be held on 14 April 2016 at the King’s College Centre at the University of Aberdeen.

A full programme and speaker details for both conferences will be published shortly – so watch this space for more information and for details on delegate prices and sponsorship/ exhibition packages.

collaboration4For information on advertising opportunities in Scottish Energy News, contact our Marketing Partners:


Contact Publicity

15 Newton Terrace


G3 7PJ Tel:

0141 204 2042


Pixie Energy

Pixie logo Pixie Energy is an incubator and a facilitator of strategic research and project work, focusing on energy regulation, policy and markets at the local and national level. Find out more about Pixie Energy here.

Local Energy Matters: Scotland

Local Energy Matters: Scotland is a free-to-download brochure with a focus on energy tariffs in the two Scottish electricity distribution regions, as well news on local energy and low-carbon schemes.

Previous editions can be download here.

Scottish energy market overview

You can read an overview of the Scottish energy market here.

Scottish Government energy feed